综上所述，确切无疑的，至少当时，Nesvizhevsky等认为他们观测到的是引力的量子态（Quantum states of gravity）！

在报道仅发布两周后，即2002年2月1日，弦理论专家李淼就在《三思科学》电子杂志2002年第2期  总第8期    http://www.oursci.org/magazine/200202/020202.htm>上发文怀疑《自然》网站记者的报导不准确，并由此修改新华社的报导。根据以上理由，我个人认为李淼对记者的怀疑是根本站不住脚的！不知你们和广大网友如何认为呢？

另外，由于本人孤陋寡闻，不知国际上其它国家的科学家对该实验的态度：实验观测到的是引力的量子态呢？还是中子的“量子行为”呢？有没有类似的讨论？麻烦介绍一下。谢谢！

Published online: 17 January 2002; | doi:10.1038/news020114-8

Gravity leaps into quantum world

Tom Clarke

Researchers finally measure the subtle quantum effects of fourth fundamental force.

Far from falling smoothly, objects moving under gravity do so in lurching, quantum leaps, a French experiment has revealed^1>. The finding confirms that gravity, like the Universe's three other fundamental forces, can have a quantum effect.

Particles, such as electrons confined to their orbital shells around the nucleus of an atom, are restricted by the rules of quantum mechanics. To move from one position to another, they must jump to the next quantum state.

Theoretically, this rule holds for all matter under the influence of nature's four fundamental forces: electromagnetism, weak and strong nuclear force and gravity. But gravity, especially at small scales, is a very feeble force, making it extremely difficult to measure its quantum effects.

There's no point in looking for quantum behaviour in everyday objects. It is occurring, but the larger things become, the more subtle are the quantum effects. Even small molecules are practically immune to the weird ways of the quantum world.

Valery Nesvizhevsky and his colleagues studied ultracold neutrons (UCNs) at the Laue-Langevin Institute in Grenoble, France. These very slow-moving, uncharged particles normally team up with protons to form the nucleus of an atom. The team isolated the neutrons from the effects of the other three forces in a specially designed detector.

By following the progress of hundreds of UCNs falling from the top of the detector to the bottom, the team found that the particles exist only at certain heights. "They do not move continuously, but rather jump from one height to another as quantum theory predicts," says Nesvizhevsky.

That someone has measured quantum leaps has physicists wide-eyed. "The effects are so small it is remarkable that they can actually observe them," says Thomas Bowles, a particle physicist at Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico.

Trick questions

This satisfying trick may also have profound implications for the future of physics. "Right now, we don't have a theory of how gravity is created," says Bowles. If refined, he says, apparatus like Nesvizhevsky's could explain how gravity behaves in the quantum world - and perhaps where it comes from.

    "Ifyou're searching for something in fundamental physics, this is a very clean system," agrees Nesvizhevsky. It should allow researchers to pick apart some of the niggling questions about the fundamental properties of matter.

It might even be possible, suggests Bowles, to work out why Einstein's theory of general relativity - which explains gravity and large things, such as galaxies and the Universe - doesn't tally with quantum mechanics, the physicist's handbook of the very small.